Remington 1858, New Model Army Revolver

Item Description

American Civil War era interest: Remington 1858 pattern, New Model Army .44 percussion revolver, circa 1863-1875, with Remington address, dates and model inscribed to the barrel, along with a period leather holster.

Revolver serial number - 35085

Antique Firearm Exemption (Section 58(2))

This revolver is a well-preserved example of American Civil War-era firearms and formed part of a small collection of American Civil War interest items on offer during our 1st October sale. We also offeredConfederate flags (Lot 255 & Lot 256), an 1860 pattern light cavalry sabre (Lot 270), and a collection of ephemera and artefacts (Lot 250).

Was the Remington 1858 Used in the American Civil War?

The Remington New Model Army revolver played a critical role in arming Union forces, and its superior durability and design made it one of the most important and respected handguns of the Civil War.

According to Norm Flayderman's Guide To Antique American Firearms (considered a definitive reference for collectors), Remington produced approximately 122,000 units of the .44 calibre New Model Army revolver. This high production number reflects its significant presence during the war.

Key reasons for its widespread use and popularity:

Durability: The Remington featured a solid-frame design with a top strap, making it more robust than the Colt 1860 Army, which had an open-frame construction.

Reliability: Its design allowed for easier cylinder changes in the field, giving it a practical edge in battle situations, especially for cavalry who needed to reload quickly.

Increased use after 1864: A fire at the Colt factory disrupted the supply of Colt revolvers, leading the Union to rely more heavily on Remington production.

Do Civil War-era Remingtons Hold Value?

Yes, Civil War-era Remington revolvers can hold significant value, especially when certain criteria are met. Their worth depends on key factors such as condition, authenticity, and provenance.

Collectors place a premium on revolvers that remain in original, unrestored condition. A firearm with its original finish and natural patina is generally far more valuable than one that has been re-blued or refinished, even if the work was expertly done. Signs of heavy rust, pitting, or structural damage to the frame or grips can greatly reduce the value. Matching serial numbers on the barrel and frame is another crucial detail that collectors look for, as they indicate the piece is intact and unaltered.

The documented history of the firearm can also significantly enhance value. If a revolver can be linked to a specific soldier, regiment, or notable figure from the Civil War, it may fetch a much higher price at auction.

Original Civil War-era Remingtons that are well-preserved and come with a compelling historical background tend to retain and even increase in value over time, making them highly sought-after by collectors and enthusiasts alike.

Is Your Remington 1858 an Original or a Replica? 

The Remington 1858, New Model Army revolver, is a prized piece of Civil War history, but with countless modern reproductions available, it's important to know whether you own an authentic antique or a replica.

Here are a few things to look out for to help you spot a replica:

Most replicas are made by Italian manufacturers like Uberti, Pietta, or Armi San Marco and will have these names marked on the gun. The correct barrel marking should be: 'PATENTED SEPT. 14, 1858 / E. REMINGTON & SONS, ILION, NEW YORK, U.S.A. / NEW MODEL.' Replicas often have a shinier, more uniform finish and may be made from modern steel or kits. Authentic Civil War-era Remingtons were produced between 1863 and 1875; originals show wear consistent with age and use, not artificial wear. Look out for matching serial numbers found under the barrel (beneath the loading lever) and under the left grip panel, and also for any military inspection marks, such as Sub-inspector stamps or faint cartouches on the grip. Another big difference is that screws and parts on replicas use metric sizes, unlike originals, where inch-based measurements are used.

Thinking of Selling? Get a Free Expert Valuation

If you own an item that you believe could be of interest, whether it’s similar to the one featured or something entirely unique, RWB Auctions welcomes you to bring it in for a free, no-obligation valuation. With a competitive seller's commission of just 10% + VAT, our monthly Antiques & Interiors Sales include full cataloguing, expert photography, and targeted marketing, ensuring your item gets the attention it deserves. Our team will keep you informed every step of the way.

Valuations are available at our Royal Wootton Bassett offices on the High Street every Monday and Tuesday, or you can email us at office@rwbauctions.com to start the conversation.

Whether you're curious or ready to sell, we’re here to help.